Employee benefits benchmarking for automotive businesses

Are you keeping pace in the race for talent?

A practical guide for UK automotive business owners, managing directors, HR leaders and finance directors.

The UK automotive industry runs on specialist skills. Whether your business manufactures components, develops vehicle technology, operates dealerships, maintains fleets or repairs vehicles, the quality of your people has a direct effect on productivity, customer service and growth. Yet finding and keeping those people is becoming increasingly difficult.

The Institute of the Motor Industry reported in March 2026 that approximately 16,000 roles remained unfilled across the sector. The automotive vacancy rate stood at 2.7%, compared with a UK average of 2.3%, with particular pressure affecting experienced technicians and specialist roles in body repair, paint and diagnostics.

At the same time, automotive businesses are competing for engineering, technology and digital skills with sectors such as energy, aerospace and advanced manufacturing. The Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders also highlights the importance of attracting new talent while retaining and developing the existing workforce as vehicle technology changes. Pay will always matter. But it is rarely the whole story.

The wider employment offer, including career development, working conditions, culture, flexibility and employee benefits, can influence whether somebody joins your business, stays with it or accepts an approach from a competitor.


Employee benefits benchmarking for automotive businesses

How do you know whether your employee benefits are genuinely competitive?

The answer begins with benchmarking.

What is employee benefits benchmarking?

Employee benefits benchmarking is the process of comparing your current arrangements against relevant market evidence. A good benchmarking exercise does not simply produce a list showing which benefits other employers provide. It considers:

  • Which benefits you currently offer
  • Who is eligible for each benefit
  • How much the business and employees contribute
  • Whether benefits differ by grade, location or workforce group
  • How your benefit levels compare with appropriate employers
  • How employees use and value the support available
  • Whether your arrangements remain affordable and sustainable
  • How effectively benefits are communicated
  • Whether your overall package supports recruitment and retention

The comparison should be relevant to your business. An independent dealership group may need a different approach from a vehicle manufacturer, engineering consultancy, parts distributor or electric vehicle technology company.

Size matters too. Comparing a 150-person component manufacturer with a global vehicle manufacturer could give a misleading impression of what is normal, affordable or practical.

Benchmarking should provide context for a decision. It should not dictate the answer.


Why benchmarking matters in the automotive sector

1. Skilled people have choices – Demand remains concentrated in technical automotive roles. Vehicle technicians accounted for approximately 24% of job postings in the Institute of the Motor Industry March 2026 briefing, while experienced, workshop-ready technicians continued to be difficult to recruit. That means candidates may be comparing several employment opportunities.

Salary is likely to be the first consideration, particularly while household finances remain under pressure. However, two similar salaries can look very different once the wider employment package is taken into account.

Benefits such as healthcare support, life assurance, income protection, employee assistance, financial wellbeing, discounts and family-related support can contribute to the employee’s overall view of an employer.

Benchmarking helps you understand whether that wider package strengthens your offer or quietly places you behind your competitors.

2. Automotive workforces are rarely uniform – A single automotive business may employ:

  • Production and assembly employees
  • Vehicle technicians
  • Engineers and technical specialists
  • Warehouse and logistics teams
  • Sales and customer service employees
  • Managers and corporate staff
  • Apprentices and graduates
  • Mobile or field-based employees

These groups may have different needs. For example, an engineer considering several technology-focused employers may look at healthcare, income protection and long-term career support. A workshop employee may place more immediate value on access to physiotherapy, dental support, optical costs or a straightforward health cash plan. A younger employee may be particularly interested in financial wellbeing, discounts and accessible mental health support.

This does not mean every employee needs a completely different benefits package. It does mean that benchmarking solely at company level can hide important gaps between workforce groups.

IHC approaches automotive benefits through the combined lens of workforce need, employee value, affordability and wider market practice, rather than assuming that one package will suit manufacturing, engineering, sales, distribution and corporate employees equally.

3. An expensive package is not necessarily a competitive one – It is possible to spend heavily on employee benefits without creating much visible value. This can happen when:

  • Employees do not know what is available
  • Eligibility rules are difficult to understand
  • Benefits are poorly matched to the workforce
  • Several services overlap
  • Providers operate separately with little co-ordination
  • Usage and employee experience are not reviewed
  • The package has developed through individual renewals rather than a clear strategy

The CIPD Reward Survey: Focus on Employee Benefits 2026 states that 77% of surveyed organisations had objectives for their employee benefits package, but 22% had no objectives. It also found that only 31% of employers with benefit objectives linked them to productivity or business performance.

For an automotive business, that distinction matters. Benefits should not simply exist because they have always been there. Each significant area of spend should have a clear purpose. That purpose might be to:

  • Strengthen recruitment
  • Retain specialist employees
  • Provide access to health support
  • Reduce the effect of absence
  • Protect employees and their families
  • Improve financial resilience
  • Create a more consistent reward proposition
  • Demonstrate that the business values its people

Benchmarking can identify where the business is spending above the market but achieving limited employee value. It can also reveal modestly priced improvements that employees may notice and appreciate.

4. Benefits need to keep pace with changing skills –

The automotive workforce is changing alongside vehicle technology. The transition towards electric, connected and increasingly software-led vehicles is increasing demand for different technical and digital capabilities. The Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders identifies engineers, designers, programmers, chemists and fabricators among the skills required as the sector changes. As the people you need change, the benefits proposition may need to change too.

A package designed ten years ago around a relatively traditional workforce may not be as effective when recruiting software engineers, battery specialists, data professionals or employees moving into automotive from the technology and energy sectors.

Those candidates may judge your employment offer against businesses outside automotive. A narrow comparison with your closest automotive competitors may therefore miss part of the picture. A strong benchmark should consider:

  • Direct automotive competitors
  • Employers of a similar size
  • Businesses in the same region
  • Other sectors competing for the same skills
  • Appropriate wider UK market evidence

What should an automotive benefits review examine?

Benefit design – Consider the level of cover, eligibility, employee contributions, waiting periods and any differences between workforce groups.

For insured benefits, evaluation may include private medical insurance, health cash plans, dental cover, life assurance, income protection and critical illness cover. Wider provision could include employee assistance, occupational health, virtual healthcare, financial wellbeing, retail discounts, electric vehicle schemes and cycle-to-work arrangements.

The review should not assume that more cover is always better. The objective is to establish whether the design is suitable, valued and affordable.

Cost and value – Headline premium or contract cost is only one measure. Employers should also consider:

  • Cost per eligible employee
  • Cost per enrolled employee
  • Employee contribution levels
  • Renewal history
  • Claims and utilisation, where appropriate data is available
  • Service performance
  • Administration time
  • Communication and engagement
  • Areas of duplication
  • The financial effect of possible design changes

A cheaper alternative may provide poorer access, greater disruption or less suitable cover. Equally, a long-standing arrangement should not be retained without considering whether it still offers reasonable value.

Employee understanding – A benefit cannot support recruitment or retention if nobody understands it. The review should test whether employees know:

  • What benefits they have
  • When they can use them
  • Whether family members are covered
  • Where to go for help
  • What the main limitations are
  • How employer-funded benefits may affect their tax position
  • What choices they need to make and by when

Communication should also reflect the workforce. Office-based employees may respond to email or an online platform, while workshop, manufacturing, warehouse and field-based employees may require different routes.

Employee experience – Provider literature describes what a service is intended to deliver. Employee experience shows what happens in practice. Relevant evidence may include:

  • Employee feedback
  • Enquiries and complaints
  • Claims and utilisation data
  • Access difficulties
  • Provider service information
  • Reasons employees decline or cancel cover
  • Recruitment and exit feedback

One IHC automotive client example involved a specialist Warwickshire automotive business with workshop, technical, sales, administration and marketing employees. Its company-wide health cash plan continued to show strong use across optical, dental and physiotherapy claims, supported by ongoing governance and employee communications. This demonstrates the value of reviewing actual workforce usage rather than judging a benefit by its product name alone.


Employee benefits benchmarking for automotive businesses

Five questions every automotive business owner should ask

1. Would our employment package help us recruit the people we need next?
2. Are we competitive for technicians, engineers and digital specialists, not just our general workforce?
3. Do our employees understand the value of what we already provide?
4. Are we paying for services that overlap or receive little meaningful use?
5. Can we clearly explain why each major benefit is provided and what outcome it is intended to support?

If the honest answer to several of these questions is “we do not know”, that is not necessarily evidence of a poor benefits package. It is evidence that a structured review may be overdue.


Employee benefits benchmarking for automotive businesses

Common benchmarking mistakes to avoid

Comparing only with very large employers – Large manufacturers may have budgets, purchasing power and internal resources that smaller automotive businesses do not. Their approach can provide useful ideas, but it may not be the right direct benchmark.

Treating market prevalence as a recommendation – If a benefit is common, that does not automatically make it right for your workforce. If it is uncommon, that does not make it unnecessary. Prevalence data should inform a decision, not replace one.

Looking only at cost – Cost is important, but cutting a visible and valued benefit may weaken the employment offer. Conversely, maintaining an expensive arrangement with low awareness and unclear purpose may not represent good value.

Assuming employees value what the leadership team values – Senior managers, technicians, apprentices and warehouse employees may experience the same benefit very differently. Employee feedback and utilisation data can test assumptions.

Benchmarking once and filing the report away – The value comes from the decisions that follow. A benefits benchmark should result in a practical action plan, with priorities, ownership and review dates. Some actions may involve benefit changes. Others may simply require better communication, clearer eligibility or stronger provider management.


Employee benefits benchmarking for automotive businesses

How often should benefits be benchmarked?

There is no universal timetable, but employers should normally revisit their position when:

  • Recruitment becomes more difficult
  • Turnover increases in important roles
  • The workforce changes significantly
  • The business opens, closes or acquires locations
  • Benefit costs increase materially
  • Employees raise access or service concerns
  • A benefit has not been reviewed for several years
  • A merger or acquisition creates inconsistent arrangements
  • The business begins competing for new types of skill

An annual high-level review, supported by a more detailed strategic exercise when circumstances change, can help prevent benefits from becoming disconnected from the business.


Employee benefits benchmarking for automotive businesses

Benchmarking is not about winning an arms race

The purpose is not to copy every competitor or assemble the longest possible list of benefits. The strongest package is not always the most expensive. It is the one that is relevant to the workforce, understood by employees, affordable for the business and connected to clear commercial objectives.

For one automotive employer, the priority may be healthcare access for specialist engineers. For another, it may be practical everyday health support for workshop employees. Elsewhere, the biggest opportunity may be life assurance, income protection, financial wellbeing or simply clearer communication of existing provision.

Benchmarking gives business owners and HR leaders the evidence to make those choices with greater confidence.


Employee benefits benchmarking for automotive businesses

A final thought for automotive business owners

In a market where experienced and specialist employees remain difficult to find, it is risky to assume that a benefits package is competitive simply because nobody has complained. Employees may not tell you that another employer’s overall package looks stronger. They may simply accept the offer. A well-run benchmarking review can help you understand:

  • Where your package is genuinely competitive
  • Where there are gaps
  • Which benefits employees appear to value
  • Where existing spend could work harder
  • Which changes deserve priority
  • How your employment offer compares when recruiting critical skills

The starting question is not: “What additional benefits should we buy?” It is: “Are the benefits we provide helping us attract, protect and retain the people our business depends on?”

If the answer is unclear, it may be time to benchmark.


How IHC can help

IHC helps UK automotive employers review employee benefits through the combined lens of workforce need, market practice, affordability, employee value and governance. Our approach can include:

  • Reviewing current benefit design and eligibility
  • Comparing arrangements with suitable market evidence
  • Examining cost, use and employee value
  • Identifying gaps, duplication and communication issues
  • Supporting insurer and provider market reviews
  • Developing a prioritised, practical action plan

The objective is not to recommend change for its own sake. It is to help you understand what you have, how it compares and whether it remains right for your business and your people.

Start your benefits benchmark

Are your employee benefits keeping pace with the automotive employment market?

Speak to IHC about an independent review of your current arrangements and an indicative comparison with relevant UK market practice.

Important information

Benchmark information is indicative and should be considered alongside workforce needs, business objectives, affordability, provider terms and professional advice. Market prevalence alone should not be treated as evidence that a particular benefit is suitable for an individual employer.

  • Institute of the Motor Industry, Automotive Labour Market Briefing, March 2026.
  • CIPD, Reward Survey: Focus on Employee Benefits, 24 February 2026.
  • IHC internal automotive sector landing page and client success story materials, July 2026.

London skyline
 

Get in touch with us today

Call +44 (0)207 353 4099, email info@ihc.co.uk, or use the form below

On submitting this form you consent to IHC collecting your personal data. For more information please read our privacy policy.